Welcome to the blog for Prof. John Talbird's English 204 class. The purpose of this site is two-fold: 1) to continue the conversations we start in class (or to start conversations before we get to class) and 2) to practice our writing/reading on a weekly basis in an informal forum.

Thursday, November 12, 2015

Carpenters Gothic- Questions in Class


what moments are novelistic in carpenters gothic? 

 Paul constantly yells at Liz about how she never listens to him, like when he tries reading to her, or when he asks her why he always gets the broken glass cup. He is trying to get something going but in reality he is not getting anything done, and yells at Liz for not answering the phone. This creates anger, tension, hatred, between the two characters. Liz doesn't know what to do, she lives life with no purpose because she feels she cant leave anywhere. 

Gaddis doesn't write his stories like others, he writes in a way where the more you read the more you understand what the scene is about. He focuses on dialogue that is not how others write. When you read his work, you have to focus on it to know exactly what is going on, who is talking and so this creates a picture in your head of the scene and you have like a mini movie of what is going on. 

Why is this book called carpenters gothic? 

this book could be called Carpenters Gothic because the more you read the story you get a sense of how their house is set up. A dark, gloomy, not so decorated house, that symbolizes houses like carpenters gothic. Carpentens gothic is a style to design homes in a gothic way. Very dark, wooden built, and this could symbolize how Paul and Liz's marriage was dark, and wasnt going anywhere becuase it was a relationship based on "hatred" and command.









2 comments:

  1. Wow David! I was a little stuck on whether Carpenter's Gothic had to do with Carpentry lol. I guess I was overlooking the title because I understood why this novel was gothic. But your explanation seems very powerful. I like how you compare the dark house to Liz and Paul's relationship. It wasn't a stable marriage at all, but in a way it makes sense. It was based on hatred and it wasn't something that was very fulfilling to either of them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i also didn't understand why Gaddis chose this title but the reason why i made this connection was because i looked up what carpenters gothic is and saw the pictures of the homes and stuff and kinda of tied it in together on how, the story is always shown to us, the readers, that its in a house, and how they have a "dark" marriage thats why i tied it in like this, but i could be like totally wrong too lol

      Delete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.